| 4th Quarter Play-by-Play |
| Mid | 2-4 | on Ham21 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Mid | 2-4 | on Ham21 | McCallum Foote rush for 3 yards to the HAM18 (D. Fuller). |
| Mid | 3-1 | on Ham18 | Matt Rea rush for 9 yards to the HAM9 (D. Peters;A. Mitko), PENALTY MID holding 10 yards to the HAM28, NO PLAY. |
| Mid | 3-11 | on Ham28 | McCallum Foote pass complete to Zach Driscoll for 18 yards to the HAM10, 1ST DOWN MID, out-of-bounds (N. Kaleikini). |
| Mid | 1-G | on Ham10 | McCallum Foote rush for 3 yards to the HAM7 (Z. Klein). |
| Mid | 2-G | on Ham07 | McCallum Foote pass complete to Zach Driscoll for 7 yards to the HAM0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 13:18. |
| Mid | 1-G | on Ham03 | PENALTY MID false start 5 yards to the HAM8. |
| | | Jake Feury kick attempt failed (blocked) (blocked by M. MacDonald). |
| Middlebury College 43, Hamilton College 21 |
| | Drive: 7 plays, 40 yards, TOP 2:59 |
| | | Jake Feury kickoff 56 yards to the HAM9, J. Stanell return 19 yards to the HAM28, out-of-bounds (Will Bain). |
| Ham | 1-10 | on Ham28 | HAMILTON COLLEGE drive start at 13:12. |
| Ham | 1-10 | on Ham28 | J. Stanell rush for 1 yard to the HAM29 (Nick Burdeau). |
| Ham | 2-9 | on Ham29 | P. Donadio rush for no gain to the HAM29, out-of-bounds (Andrew Ackerman). |
| Ham | 3-9 | on Ham29 | J. Eck pass incomplete to G. Hoy, dropped pass. |
| Ham | 4-9 | on Ham29 | PENALTY HAM personal foul declined. |
| Ham | 4-9 | on Ham29 | G. Hoy punt 36 yards to the MID35, downed. |
| | Drive: 3 plays, 1 yard, TOP 1:14 |
| Mid | 1-10 | on Mid35 | MIDDLEBURY COLLEGE drive start at 11:58. |
| Mid | 1-10 | on Mid35 | Matt Rea rush for 13 yards to the MID48, 1ST DOWN MID (J. Kochenash). |
| Mid | 1-10 | on Mid48 | Matt Rea rush for 4 yards to the HAM48 (D. Peters), PENALTY MID face mask 15 yards to the MID33, NO PLAY. |
| Mid | 1-25 | on Mid33 | McCallum Foote pass complete to Matt Rea for 11 yards to the MID44 (A. Austin). |
| Mid | 2-14 | on Mid44 | McCallum Foote pass complete to Zach Driscoll for 16 yards to the HAM40, 1ST DOWN MID (J. Kochenash). |
| Mid | 1-10 | on Ham40 | McCallum Foote pass complete to Matt Rea for 4 yards to the HAM36. |
| Mid | 2-6 | on Ham36 | Matt Rea rush for 1 yard to the HAM35 (M. MacDonald). |
| Mid | 3-5 | on Ham35 | McCallum Foote pass complete to H. Goodkind for 4 yards to the HAM31 (J. Phelan). |
| Mid | 4-1 | on Ham31 | McCallum Foote pass complete to Billy Chapman for 11 yards to the HAM20, 1ST DOWN MID (J. Kochenash;A. Durham). |
| Mid | 1-10 | on Ham20 | McCallum Foote pass incomplete to Matthew Minno. |
| Mid | 2-10 | on Ham20 | Matt Rea rush for 20 yards to the HAM0, 1ST DOWN MID, TOUCHDOWN, clock 08:15. |
| | | Jake Feury kick attempt good. |
| Middlebury College 50, Hamilton College 21 |
| | Drive: 9 plays, 65 yards, TOP 3:46 |
| | | Jake Feury kickoff 34 yards to the HAM31, A. Fisher return 6 yards to the HAM37, out-of-bounds (Dan Pierce), PENALTY HAM personal foul 15 yards to the HAM22, 1st and 10, HAM ball on HAM22. |
| Ham | 1-10 | on Ham22 | HAMILTON COLLEGE drive start at 08:12. |
| Ham | 1-10 | on Ham22 | J. Stanell rush for 5 yards to the HAM27, out-of-bounds (M. Benedict). |
| Ham | 2-5 | on Ham27 | J. Eck pass complete to J. Jensen for 6 yards to the HAM33, 1ST DOWN HAM (Tim Patricia;Andrew Donnelly). |
| Ham | 1-10 | on Ham33 | J. Eck pass complete to S. Jia for 13 yards to the HAM46, 1ST DOWN HAM, out-of-bounds (Drew Miller). |
| Ham | 1-10 | on Ham46 | J. Eck pass complete to J. Stanell for 5 yards to the MID49 (Andrew Donnelly). |
| Ham | 2-5 | on Mid49 | S. Jia rush for 3 yards to the MID46 (M. Benedict;Tim Patricia). |
| Ham | 3-2 | on Mid46 | J. Stanell rush for 1 yard to the MID45 (Kyle Ashley). |
| Ham | 4-1 | on Mid45 | J. Stanell rush for 2 yards to the MID43, 1ST DOWN HAM (Kyle Ashley;Andrew Donnelly). |
| Ham | 1-10 | on Mid43 | J. Eck pass complete to S. Jia for 11 yards to the MID32, 1ST DOWN HAM (Drew Miller). |
| Ham | 1-10 | on Mid32 | J. Eck pass incomplete. |
| Ham | 2-10 | on Mid32 | J. Eck pass incomplete to P. Donadio, dropped pass. |
| Ham | 3-10 | on Mid32 | J. Eck pass incomplete to G. Hoy (Daniel Kenerson). |
| Ham | 4-10 | on Mid32 | J. Eck pass incomplete to P. Donadio (Andy Singley). |
| | Drive: 12 plays, 46 yards, TOP 4:26 |
| Mid | 1-10 | on Mid32 | MIDDLEBURY COLLEGE drive start at 03:46. |
| Mid | 1-10 | on Mid32 | Ryan Hislop rush for 2 yards to the MID34 (C. Glover). |
| Mid | 2-8 | on Mid34 | Ryan Hislop rush for 2 yards to the MID36 (D. Fuller). |
| Mid | 3-6 | on Mid36 | Andy Dittrich pass intercepted by A. Fisher at the MID46, A. Fisher return 0 yards to the MID46, out-of-bounds. |
| | Drive: 3 plays, 4 yards, TOP 1:31 |
| Ham | 1-10 | on Mid46 | HAMILTON COLLEGE drive start at 02:15. |
| Ham | 1-10 | on Mid46 | J. Stanell rush for 4 yards to the MID42 (Charlie Kunze). |
| Ham | 2-6 | on Mid42 | N. Ufkes rush for 1 yard to the MID41 (Charlie Kunze;G. Araujo). |
| Ham | 3-5 | on Mid41 | C. Pastorella pass incomplete to J. Jensen, dropped pass. |
| Ham | 4-5 | on Mid41 | C. Pastorella rush for 1 yard to the MID40 (Andrew Donnelly;Josh Mallin). |
| | Drive: 4 plays, 6 yards, TOP 1:32 |
| Mid | 1-10 | on Mid40 | MIDDLEBURY COLLEGE drive start at 00:43. |
| Mid | 1-10 | on Mid40 | Ryan Hislop rush for 2 yards to the MID42 (M. MacDonald;N. Ball). |
| Mid | 2-8 | on Mid42 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | Drive: 1 play, 2 yards, TOP 0:43 |
